Menu of Smittys In & Out in Elma, Washington, USA

Menu Overview

Smittys In & Out, nestled at 1424 W Main St in Elma, WA, delivers the quintessential hamburger joint experience with a local twist. This unassuming drive-thru gem excels in simplicity and quality, focusing on classic American favorites like burgers, fries, onion rings, and an intriguing fish sandwich that elevates the menu beyond the expected.

The hallmark of Smittys In & Out is their burgers — fresh, straightforward, and robustly flavored. The Bacon Cheese Deluxe and Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe stand out, loaded with savory bacon and melted cheese, creating a satisfying, hearty bite. Jennifer Pahlman’s mention of adding “goop” sauce—a blend of mayo, mustard, and dill relish—highlights the subtle flavor layers that guests can personalize, demonstrating the kitchen’s flexibility without complexity. These burgers balance juicy patties with crisp, fresh vegetables, though some diners like Jacob Garcia would appreciate consistent inclusions like lettuce and tomato in their combos.

Sides here are not mere afterthoughts. The fries and onion rings arrive perfectly seasoned and crisp, avoiding the sogginess that plagues many quick-service spots. Keira’s praise for the seasoned curly fries and onion rings speaks volumes to the kitchen’s attention to texture and seasoning, making these companion pieces worthy of closing the plate.

The fish sandwich offers a delightful alternative to the meat-heavy menu. It’s notably fresh, not rubbery, and its breading holds firm, providing a satisfying crunch that complements the tender fish inside. This item showcases Smittys’ skill in handling a variety of proteins with quality and care.

Milkshakes, including classic chocolate and more unique offerings like the blackberry milkshake lauded by Marsha Johnson, create an indulgent finish to the meal. Joe Serkoch’s exuberant praise for the chocolate milkshake underscores the craftsmanship behind their beverage offerings, blending thick creaminess with balanced sweetness.

Affordability is a mixed bag, with combo meals ranging broadly in price. Some customers find the pricing puzzling at times, as Jacob noted an unexpectedly high bill when ordering multiple meals and shakes. However, the consistently praised food quality and the friendly, speedy service in a no-frills setting offer strong value.

Little details like complimentary ketchup, a clean restroom adjacent to the lot, and a well-curated beverage list featuring Dr. Pepper, Pepsi, Coke, 7Up, and Root Beer add to the overall convenience and comfort of dining here.

In sum, Smittys In & Out is a worthwhile stop for anyone passing through Elma craving classic American diner fare elevated through fresh ingredients and thoughtful execution. Whether it’s the satisfyingly rich Bacon Cheese Deluxe, the crisp fish sandwich, or the crave-worthy shakes, this spot offers a reliable, honest taste of Americana with enough variety and quality to keep customers coming back.